Opinion
Home
The Saga
Archives
Wild Geese Shops
Bookstore
Classifieds
Heritage
News
Opinion
Key Dates
Events
WGT Forum
Gallery
Lands of Exile
Living History
Resources
Bibliography
Guest Book
Contact WGT
About Us

PROUD SPONSORS OF WGT:

David Kincaid presents "The Irish-American's Song: Songs of the Union and Confederate Irish Soldiers, 1861-1865," his long-awaited sequel to "The Irish Volunteer". With 36-page full-color booklet with lyrics, photos, and illustrations.

Adams County Irish Festival presents Derek Warfield and the Sons of Erin, traditional Irish music, a Civil War encampment, Irish dancers and vendors, and workshops for Irish instruments.


Now in paperback:
Commanding Boston's Irish Ninth, edited by Christian G. Samito
"These letters reveal the very soul of a very special Irish immigrant."
The Irish Edition
$20 fordhampress.com,
1-800-247-6553.

Only available at the Newshound Bookstore: FREMANTLE MISSION by Séan Ó Lúing. Published in 1965, it remains the best account of this tremendous Irish-American success story from 1876. NEWSHOUND: Links to Daily Newspaper Articles About Northern Ireland.

VISIT THESE OTHER FINE IRISH SITES:

Tara Hall, Headquarters for 'Fighting 69th' and Irish Brigade Memorabilia, online at Fighting69th.com.

cover
Derek Warfield tells the story of 1798 in song in Liberte '98: Songs & Ballads of 1798

Some other CDs by Derek Warfield

Get an "Irish Brigade" t-shirt or sweat shirt with the graphic shown above from the Wild Geese Today's Irish Brigade Shop

Register for The Wild Geese Today e-mail updates.

Derek Warfield's Music -- Right for Aer Lingus?

POINT / COUNTERPOINT

Roy Beggs Jr. responds to our Derek Warfield interview.

Editor's Note: Before publishing our interview with Derek Warfield, we sent excerpts to Ulster Unionist politician Roy Beggs Jr., whose complaints brought attention to, if not actually inspired, the removal of Warfield's music from Aer Lingus flights. Below is Beggs' response, which arrived in our mailbox Friday (June 20). We have lightly edited the e-mail (for punctuation and typos). Tom Madigan's reply to Beggs can be accessed here.


Roy Beggs Jr. website
Roy Beggs Jr.

Dear Tom,

Thank you for your e-mail and the selected excerpts from your interview with Mr. Warfield.

I would be happy to respond to your questions, and I would hope that you would allow me to address the misconceptions that Mr. Warfield and yourself have about me, judging by your somewhat sycophantic interview with him.

Just to be clear, I did not complain to Aer Lingus because of any antipathy to Irish music and culture. The fact is that the music of Derek Warfield and the Wolf Tones is in the opinion of many in Ireland as being sympathetic to armed militant Irish republicanism, in other words—terrorism, killing other human beings who do not agree with your political opinion. I would have thought that in the wake of 9/11 the true, evil nature of terrorism would have become clear to you.

The fact is that the music of Derek Warfield and the Wolf Tones is in the opinion of many in Ireland as being sympathetic to armed militant Irish republicanism, in other words—terrorism ...
That is why I wrote to Aer Lingus to complain about the songs they were playing on their in-flight entertainment. They are simply not appropriate for a state airline. I believe that I was totally justified in bringing this matter up, and I have been supported by many people who would call themselves Irish nationalists. Songs like "Ten Dead Men," and "Remember Bobby Sands," (a convicted terrorist who starved himself to death on a hunger strike)—what ... sort of music is that? Your comparison between playing Warfield songs and playing "God Save the Queen" is completely erroneous. A more accurate comparison would be British Airways playing "Here Lies a Soldier of the UVF." Would that be acceptable? Of course not!

On a wider scale, could I respond to some of the assumptions you and Mr. Warfield make about me? You say:

"Your philosophy is inimical to the cause of many in Ireland ..." What is the philosophy you are referring to, Tom? What is the "cause" to which you refer? Presumably, you are referring to Ulster Unionism, which basically adheres to the belief in the unity of the British nations as reflected in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The cause you refer to is presumably an all-Ireland republic. Am I not allowed to hold my views?? If not, that is a very dangerous position for you to take, it smacks of the notion of racial purity and the gas chambers. I am proud to say that my forefathers fought against that type of fascism in Europe 60 years ago—while the Irish Republic remained neutral.

A more accurate comparison would be British Airways playing "Here Lies a Soldier of the UVF." Would that be acceptable?
"This pro-English guy" ... I am an Irishman who also embraces a wider British identity, and is opposed to narrow, monocultural Irish nationalism. If that makes me pro-English, then so be it. Many Americans see no contradiction in calling themselves "Irish Americans." Irish Americans might also pause to reflect on who has been the most steadfast ally of the USA in the "war against terrorism."

"He lives in such a privileged, controlled ..." Perhaps you could name one privilege that I enjoy that is denied anyone else in the multiethnic pluralist liberal democracy that is the United Kingdom.

"The man would begrudge the air that I breathe." No, Mr. Warfield, I would not, all I want is for you and your friends to recognise my right to exist, and not try to force me against my free will into an all-Ireland republic through the use of bombs and bullets. Plus, I would prefer that you didn't write songs glorifying this tactic.

"Obviously, Begg is a Unionist and he's going to do what Unionists always do, that would be expected from him." Why don't you say what you mean rather than throwing out vague insults. Is it because you don't really know what you are talking about???

If you seriously think that the music of Derek Warfield speaks to the "heart and soul of the Irish people," then you must have a very black heart and a very dark soul.
I could go on, but, in general, the comments you have allowed me to see reveal quite clearly who the "intolerant" people are in this situation. A cursory look at your "historical" (should that be "hysterical") website shows that you have a very one-dimensional view of Irish history and a warped view of Irish patriotism. Your letter regarding the ex-IRA prisoner (Editor's Note: Ciaran Ferry) is actually quite sick.

Have you never heard of the Scots Irish and the contribution they made to the founding of the United States of America?

I would thoroughly recommend that you undertake some historical research into that aspect of your Irish American heritage. It might, just might open your eyes.

Thanks for taking the time to write to me, I will continue to campaign for the ending of terrorism and work for peace and reconciliation between the communities in Northern Ireland. Maybe you should do the same.

Yours sincerely,

Roy Beggs

P.S. If you seriously think that the music of Derek Warfield speaks to the "heart and soul of the Irish people," then you must have a very black heart and a very dark soul.

WHY AER LINGUS PULLED THE PLUG
  • Derek Warfield on His Aer Lingus Disappearing Act
  • POINT: Beggs Says No to Warfield
  • COUNTERPOINT: Madigan to Beggs—Simply Change the Channel
  • WGT POLL: You and Aer Lingus -- Flying or Parting?
  • Hear Derek Warfield at the Upcoming Adams County Irish Festival
  • The Official Website of Derek Warfield
  • The Official Website of Ulster Unionist Legislator Roy Beggs Jr.
  • Aer Lingus: Ireland's National Airline
  • GOOGLE Search: Warfield, Aer Lingus
  • More History/Heritage News from WGT
  • Are you one of The Wild Geese? Show the world with a hat, shirt, or other item displaying one of these Wild Geese graphics.

    Wild Geese Today Logo

    Irish America: The Fenian Tradition

    Wild Geese
    Harp Flag

    Looking for Irish Coats of Arms or Irish Family History Data?
    A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W Y
    Click a Letter to look up your family!

    Copyright © 2003, GAR Media.
    All rights reserved.

    Animating Membership Badge Showcase